A Not So Rosy Look at Nonprofit Salaries

As most of us in the field know, nonprofit salaries usually fall short of their counterparts in the private sector.  A new posting at Payscale, Nonprofit Jobs: Flexibility and Opportunity at a Cost, points out there are opportunities for late career changes and baby boomers to fill the gap in personnel recently reported by Bridgespan. The article also points out the advantages of working for nonprofit, and that shouldn’t focus only on compensation.

An especially interesting quote was from Roberta Chinsky Matuson who said, “the most challenging part will be for the employee to recognize that they will work with an extremely limited budget and resources.”  As a technology resource focused on online fundraising, I believe even the smallest organizations with limited resources always have options resources – even though it can be challenging.

Report from Westchester Not-for-Profit Leadership Summit

On Monday, May 14, I attended the 5th annual Westchester Not-For-Profit Leadership Summit.  Hilary Clinton spoke at breakfast and Thomas Tierney of the Bridgespan Group presented during lunch.  I also attended sessions on the fragile relationship between nonprofit CEOs and boards as well as a nice review of online fundraising strategies.

Probably the most interesting insight was presented by Tom Tierney, who discussed nonprofits’ difficulties in recruiting and retaining executive talent.  With many nonprofit leaders approaching retirement age, this is becoming an even larger problem.  While there are no easy solutions, he offered a few observations:

  1. Nonprofits can no longer rely on the system of ‘hiring a friend.’  New pools of talent must be found;  it’s not always necessary (or possible) to find someone from another nonprofit with a similar mission that is already a senior executive.
  2. Executive Directors usually spend most of their time on fundraising, but this is not enough to insure a nonprofit’s continuing ability to achieve its mission.
  3. Nonprofits often go outside the organization to recruit talent (while corporations often hire from within).  Nonprofits must offer on the job training and coaching, as well as job rotation to develop talent

He also commented that he considered work in the nonprofit sector to be more difficult than anything he has done in the private sector;  many who switch from for-profit to nonprofit mistakenly feel that their jobs will be easier and less stressful.

More on Bridgespan’s site on The Nonprofit Sector’s Leadership Deficit